All articlesWebsites

Squarespace vs Wix vs a custom website: which should you choose?

4 min read

There is no single best option. Website builders are great for many small businesses, and custom sites are worth it for others. The right choice depends on what your site needs to do, who will maintain it, and how much you expect it to grow.

Here's an honest comparison of the most common options, what each is good and bad at, and a simple way to decide. Plans and prices change often, so check each platform's current pricing before you commit.

What to compare

  • Ease of use: can you update it yourself without breaking anything?
  • Design: does it look professional and work well on phones?
  • Features: bookings, shop, forms, memberships, blogs.
  • Speed and SEO: how fast it loads and how easily Google can understand it.
  • Ongoing cost: subscriptions, apps and plugins.
  • Ownership and flexibility: how easy is it to move or change later?

Squarespace

  • Good for: service businesses, portfolios, restaurants and cafés that want a clean, design-led look.
  • Strengths: polished templates, easy to keep tidy, hosting and security handled for you.
  • Watch out for: less flexibility if you need unusual features or layouts.

Squarespace suits owners who want a good-looking site with minimal fuss. Its templates are hard to make look bad, which is a real advantage if design is not your strength.

Wix

  • Good for: owners who want to drag things anywhere and build it themselves.
  • Strengths: very flexible editor, lots of built-in apps for bookings, events and more.
  • Watch out for: that freedom makes it easy to end up with a cluttered layout that looks messy on phones.

Wix suits people who like to tinker. Check your site on a phone after every change, because what looks right on a laptop can look very different on mobile.

Shopify

  • Good for: selling products online.
  • Strengths: built for checkout, inventory, shipping and taxes, with a large app store.
  • Watch out for: monthly app costs can add up.

If selling products is the main job of your site, Shopify is usually the safest starting point. It handles the hard parts of online selling, and it also works with in-person sales if you have a shop or sell at markets.

WordPress

  • Good for: content-heavy sites, blogs, and businesses that want lots of plugins and options.
  • Strengths: very flexible, huge range of themes and plugins, you can host it almost anywhere.
  • Watch out for: updates, security and plugin conflicts need regular attention.

WordPress is powerful but needs looking after. If nobody updates it, it can become slow or insecure over time.

A custom-built website

  • Good for: businesses that need specific features, connections to other tools, top speed, or a design that stands out.
  • Strengths: built exactly for you, can connect to your CRM, booking system or automations, and you are not limited by a template.
  • Watch out for: higher upfront cost, and you need someone to maintain it. Make sure you own the code and the domain.

Custom makes sense when your website is part of how your business runs, for example when it takes bookings that feed your calendar, sends leads to your CRM, or needs a look your competitors cannot copy from a template.

Switching later

Moving between platforms is possible but rarely painless. Pages, products and blog posts may need to be rebuilt, and links can break, which can hurt your Google ranking if it isn't handled carefully. Choose something you can live with for a few years, and keep your domain registered in your own name so you can always move.

Quick way to decide

  1. Mostly selling products online? Start with Shopify.
  2. A simple site with a few pages that you want to edit yourself? Squarespace or Wix.
  3. Lots of articles and content, with someone to maintain it? WordPress.
  4. Need custom features, integrations or a stand-out design? Go custom.
  5. Whatever you choose, make sure the domain is registered in your name.

Questions to ask yourself first

  1. Who will update the site week to week, and how comfortable are they with tech?
  2. Do I need to sell online, take bookings or accept payments?
  3. Does the site need to connect to other tools, like a CRM or calendar?
  4. How important is standing out visually compared to competitors?
  5. Will the site grow a lot over the next few years, with more pages or features?

Your answers point you in the right direction more reliably than any feature list. If you answer "me, not very comfortable, no, no, not very, no", a website builder is probably perfect. If most answers point to growth, integrations and a unique look, it may be time to go custom.

Whichever you choose

The platform matters less than the basics: a clear headline, a working phone number and contact form, real photos, fast pages and good page titles. A simple builder site that gets those right will beat a fancy custom site that doesn't.

Not sure? Book a free call. We'll tell you honestly if a builder is enough for you.

Need a website that brings in customers?

Tell us what you have and what you need. We quote after a quick, free call.